menu
search
a shiftting macro landscape qe china and europe

A shifting macro landscape: QE, China, and Europe

John Butler, Macro Strategist
Mark Sullivan, CFA, CMT, Head of Alternatives and Portfolio Manager
2023-08-31
Archived info
Archived pieces remain available on the site. Please consider the publish date while reading these older pieces.

The views expressed are those of the authors at the time of writing. Other teams may hold different views and make different investment decisions. The value of your investment may become worth more or less than at the time of original investment. While any third-party data used is considered reliable, its accuracy is not guaranteed. For professional, institutional, or accredited investors only.

Today’s macro landscape represents a marked shift from a risk-asset-friendly environment to a challenging new regime. Investors must consider how to navigate a potentially much more volatile future given deglobalization, heightened inflation, and the potential for increased cyclicality. In our view, investing with a macro lens will be increasingly critical in the years ahead.

Here, we explore the investment implications of the end of quantitative easing (QE) programs, the state of the Chinese cycle, and an evolving outlook on Europe. 

The move away from a common QE path

Over the last 10 years, there has often been a disconnect between risk markets and the macro backdrop as central banks pumped US$20 trillion of liquidity into the markets globally (Figure 1). This elevated risk assets to valuations significantly above where macro factors would have suggested. But now, every major central bank except for the Bank of Japan is reversing course and tightening policy. Notably, the developed world’s policy homogeneity (aggressive monetary policy and conservative fiscal policy) since the European sovereign crisis created correspondingly homogenous cycle and inflation outcomes.

Figure 1
a-shifting-macro-landscape-qe-china-and-europe-fig1

As central banks shift from substantial net buyers to net sellers, we are moving into a sharply different liquidity environment that could create headwinds for risk assets. Importantly, over the past decade, different central banks’ QE policies have impacted different markets. For example, US QE influenced equity markets, while ECB QE had a greater impact on high-yield and investment-grade credit markets. As flows start to reverse, it is important to keep in mind how specific central bank actions could impact distinct markets. 

With inflation, volatility, and cyclicality all increasing, we are also now in a world where we can no longer expect downside risk to be met by rate cuts and QE injections. Instead, fiscal policy will be the more common tool of choice and central banks will be focused on containing inflation pressures.

As this environment evolves, there will be a wider distribution of outcomes as countries adopt unique policy options based on their country- and region-specific circumstances. For instance, in recent years, aggressive use of fiscal policy put the US on a different trajectory from the rest of the world. Relative country stories like this are likely to become more prevalent and offer opportunities for active management.

The global impact of the Chinese cycle

Another crucial consideration as we navigate the current macro environment is the state of the Chinese economy. Recently, it has clearly contracted significantly, due in part to the country’s zero-COVID policy. It will be difficult to have conviction on where the bottom of the Chinese cycle will be found until we have more clarity on the future of this policy. However, any significant positive signal on COVID policy and COVID prevalence itself will be helpful to understanding when the cycle will turn.

Importantly, the last time a China slowdown occurred during COVID, many global economies did not slow as historical relationships would have suggested, as the impact was offset by reopening. Today, developed markets are facing a much different landscape. As China drives marginal demand for many commodities and exports, we believe this slowdown may have a higher chance of feeding through to the rest of the world due to lower demand, weak supply, and higher inflation. This may increase the chance of recession in many markets.

This environment could also have significant implications for the Chinese currency. China is currently preventing the currency from loosening as much as the relative growth story between China and the US implies. The CNY is very strong relative to a trade basket as there has been substantial demand in developed markets but that seems to be falling away. This dynamic will significantly depend on whether or not developed economies like the US move into a recessionary environment.

The new environment in Europe

Though several factors seem to imply a negative outlook for Europe — most notably geopolitical conflict, an energy crisis, and inflation — a few key shifts make us more structurally optimistic on Europe than at any point in the last two decades. We’ve been structurally negative on Europe over the past 10 to 15 years due to a lack of integration combined with the inability or unwillingness of key European powers to establish pro-growth domestic policies and make adequate use of fiscal policy. But over the last year, Europe has seen a shift to a pro-fiscal environment that could mean European fiscal policy going forward may look dramatically different than it has for the last decade. 

This does not mean all of Europe’s very real problems are fixed, but it could mean an end to the low-growth, low-inflation environment the market seems to expect. We expect greater macro dispersion across the region as well, producing opportunities for active investors, and particularly in industries that are poised to navigate this cyclical environment. We think this opportunity is not priced into European assets and is underappreciated by the market.

Bottom line on investing in today’s macro environment

Markets are rapidly shifting, and in our view, it is critical for investors to prepare for increased cyclicality, volatility, and inflation. Importantly, we believe the end of QE, the evolving Chinese cycle, and a changing European market will contribute to macro opportunities and risks that make active management essential going forward.

Experts

Related insights

Showing of Insights Posts
Monthly Market Snapshot: August 2022 Continue reading
event
Article
2022-11-15
The Fed’s “lean, leave, then clean” strategy Continue reading
event
Quick Take
2022-12-31
India: Growth drivers are in place Continue reading
event
Quick Take
2022-12-31
Time to rethink your return-seeking allocation? Continue reading
event
Article
2023-09-30
Germany: Reducing Russian energy dependence in a hurry Continue reading
event
Quick Take
2022-12-30

Read next