- Research Manager
Skip to main content
- Insights
- Capabilities
- Funds
- Sustainability
- About Us
- My Account
The views expressed are those of the authors at the time of writing. Other teams may hold different views and make different investment decisions. The value of your investment may become worth more or less than at the time of original investment. While any third-party data used is considered reliable, its accuracy is not guaranteed. For professional, institutional, or accredited investors only.
This is an excerpt from our 2023 Investment Outlook, in which specialists from across our investment platform share insights on the economic and market forces that we expect to influence portfolios in the year to come. This is a chapter in the Alternative Investment Outlook section.
With interest rates on the rise at the fastest pace in years, allocators are understandably wondering whether fixed income can still perform certain roles in multi-asset portfolios, including return consistency and downside protection (Figure 1). In some cases, this is driving interest in hedge funds as a partial substitute for traditional fixed income allocations. The unconstrained nature of hedge funds can potentially make them a valuable building block for outcome-oriented solutions such as a fixed income substitute portfolio designed for different interest-rate environments.
A common approach has been to build a multi-manager hedge fund portfolio with bond-like volatility and minimal correlation to equities. Allocators constructing such a portfolio often focus on how to weight various categories of hedge fund strategies (e.g., Macro and Relative Value) to navigate certain market environments. But we have found that the behavioral profiles of hedge fund categories have been more similar than not in recent years, suggesting that a portfolio structured in this way may be less diversified than it appears.
Instead, we believe a style-factor lens can help allocators build portfolios of hedge funds that are more connected to the desired roles of fixed income. Here, we share some of our recent research on the behavior of our fundamental factors in different rate environments. We then explain how those insights might be applied to the process of selecting hedge funds for a multi-manager portfolio.
As members of Wellington’s Fundamental Factor Team, we use a “role-based” framework to help us understand portfolio managers’ alpha profiles. Using this framework, we evaluated which factors best filled the roles of a traditional fixed income allocation in historical periods of large moves in interest rates (up or down).1 Among the notable observations:
Having identified the factors that can potentially fill fixed income roles in specific rate environments, we analyzed the four main hedge fund strategy groups — Equity Hedge, Macro, Relative Value, Event Driven — to identify common factor profiles of funds within each group. Our high-level conclusion was that three of the four hedge fund strategy groups had relatively similar behavioral profiles, albeit with large differences in the proportion of managers with significant factor tilts. Specifically, a meaningful number of managers across Equity Hedge, Relative Value, and Event Driven strategies had long exposure to Risk Seeking factors and/or Mean Reversion factors, with some having short exposure to Risk Aversion factors as well.
We think this emphasizes the need to not be overly reliant on top-down strategy group allocations when assembling a portfolio of hedge funds. Instead, we see a case for focusing first on mapping the roles of individual hedge funds to key portfolio objectives. We think this can help mitigate the risk of having a portfolio that appears well diversified on the surface but fails to deliver a consistent profile across different market environments.
In our recent paper, “Can hedge funds behave if fixed income doesn’t? A manager-selection view”, we provide a detailed case study of how this can work in practice, including profiles of hypothetical portfolios of hedge funds designed for different interest-rate environments (Figure 2) — an illustration of the potential benefits of using a role- and behavior-based approach to increase alignment between manager research, the investment process, and portfolio objectives.
1Largest 5% of weekly moves in 10-year US Treasury nominal yield over 10 years ended 31 December 2021. Sources: Wellington, HFRI, FactSet, Bloomberg. Additional information on this data is available upon request. PAST RESULTS ARE NOT NECESSARILY INDICATIVE OF FUTURE RESULTS AND AN INVESTMENT CAN LOSE VALUE.
Experts
READ NEXT
Stay up to date with the latest market insights and our point of view.
Can hedge funds play the role?
How should investors select the most suitable types of hedge funds for specific roles? Members of our Investment Strategy & Solutions Group offer a simple and intuitive framework that can help.
Picking the right building blocks for a climate-aware portfolio
For asset owners integrating climate change into their multi-asset portfolios, members of our Investment Strategy & Solutions Group offer five important insights.
WellSaid: Partnering with climate founders
Wellington head of private climate Greg Wasserman discusses his team's approach to helping private companies progress along their growth journey
Venture capital outlook: Signals point to a brighter 2024
Our private investing team sees positive signals indicating that the recent downturn in venture capital may have hit bottom. Just as privates trailed the public market correction in 2022, we believe they will follow its recovery.
No more free lunch: Impact of higher interest rates on private equity strategies
We explain what the direct and indirect rate exposure of buyouts, venture capital, growth equity, secondaries, and fund-of-funds mean for investors.
Private market perspectives
Hear from private market experts across our early-stage venture, climate growth, late-stage biomedical, late-stage growth, private credit, and ESG teams.
Annual message from our CEO: At a crossroads
CEO Jean Hynes offers perspectives on the current macro and market environment, including the need to challenge long-held assumptions, prepare for persistent disruption, and consider the resulting investment opportunities and risks.
Private biotech: Immunology and inflammation’s third wave
Our experts discuss how I&I is building on industry progress to offer new treatment solutions and interesting opportunities for private biotech investors.
Why income-seeking investors need to look across asset classes
Income plays an even more crucial role in portfolios than many of us realise, contributing a significant portion of returns for multi-asset portfolios. But with cash rates at around 5%, the world of income has changed. This should prompt investors to take a fresh look across asset classes to see where opportunities lie.
Five key ESG topics for private companies in 2024
See where our ESG for Private Investments team is focusing to minimize investment risk and maximize company value in 2024 and beyond.
Alternative Investment Outlook
This collection provides timely ideas across the spectrum of alternative investments -- including hedge funds, private equity, and private credit.
URL References
Related Insights