- Impact Measurement and Management Practice Leader
Skip to main content
- Insights
- Capabilities
- Funds
- Sustainability
- About Us
- My Account
The views expressed are those of the authors at the time of writing. Other teams may hold different views and make different investment decisions. The value of your investment may become worth more or less than at the time of original investment. While any third-party data used is considered reliable, its accuracy is not guaranteed. For professional, institutional, or accredited investors only.
As well as investing in solutions that help to mitigate climate change (through reducing or avoiding greenhouse gas emissions), we see a major role for impact investment in solutions that help bolster resilience against growing climate uncertainty and volatility. The research we undertake with our climate science partners at Woodwell Climate Research Center shows how urgent adapting to climate change has become, with adverse climate events already increasing in frequency and intensity. Impact investors can help direct much-needed capital to the most exposed communities and regions and tap into the attractive impact and return potential associated with the expanding range of investment opportunities in climate resilience.
Impact measurement is a vital part of the investment process for impact funds. It aims to use both qualitative and quantitative data to track whether a portfolio and its underlying investments are having the intended net positive effect on people and/or planet. However, measuring the impact of climate resilience solutions remains a real challenge for us and the wider industry. Below we share our latest perspectives on how to tackle this challenge, using the more established measurement of climate mitigation as a reference point. Based on our observations, we outline approaches that we think may help investors deal with some of the inherent conceptual and methodological difficulties of measuring impact in this critical field.
Articulating the impact case for a resilience solution and measuring, monitoring and verifying the results means overcoming several hurdles. Figure 1 lists key hurdles and differences with the more familiar terrain of climate mitigation. Some of the most important ones are:
With these difficulties in mind, what are the main points that investors need to consider when measuring the impact of climate resilience solutions?
Investors need to create a detailed picture of the anticipated impact of climate change and the local vulnerabilities. Guiding questions that can help achieve those goals include:
Investors need to clearly explain how the product or service offered by the company will contribute to reducing vulnerability/strengthening resilience and articulate the underlying assumptions on how change might happen. Examples include assessing:
It is also imperative to revisit these hypotheses and assumptions regularly to account for uncertain climate projections and socioeconomic changes.
The indicators chosen to measure impact should plausibly demonstrate the contribution of the solution to climate resilience bearing in mind the relevant context. It is essential to make the most of the available data — even if it doesn’t capture the entire story.
Context: Increased frequency of extreme weather is leading to a higher risk of power outages and an increased need for backup power supply in the home. For example, around 83% of reported major power outages in the US have been linked to weather-related events.1 When looking at solutions that increase household resilience to power outages such as backup, flexible or renewable power, the ultimate climate resilience benefit relates to a decrease in vulnerability to power outages. This is a narrow measure that is difficult to capture in one number, as it is dependent on hard-to-predict factors such as the likely number of weather-related events or people’s future behaviour. Using a simple output-related metric such as the number of units sold, or number of households served, supported by detailed research linking these metrics to better climate resilience is an imperfect, yet practical solution.
Not all companies publish the necessary data to demonstrate the impact that their products or services have on climate resilience. Speaking directly to company management, sustainability, or investor relations teams to highlight the importance of this disclosure is crucial.
Context: Many companies are more used to disclosing environmental data on their own operations products and services on the end consumer. Actively engaging with companies to highlight the importance of climate resilience metrics (or the necessary proxies to calculate them) may help to encourage more detailed disclosure in the future.
Solutions that increase climate resilience are interdependent on various environmental and socioeconomic factors, which are difficult to control. Success is not guaranteed if implemented in isolation. Hence the importance of also looking at a wide range of data, which, while not attributable to the project in isolation, can still have a bearing on its success.
Context: When looking at a solution that aims to help increase the yield of a certain crop by making the growing process more resistant to extreme weather, we would also consider factors affecting the overall food supply chain in the relevant region as an additional lens. We can use this data to assess the significance of this particular solution in a wider, regional context.
In combination, we think these guidelines serve as useful considerations for investors looking to measure the impact of investments in climate resilience. In our view, the inherent methodological challenges and the complex objectives of resilience measurement mean that any approach must be flexible enough to work with often imperfect and limited data sets.
The challenge of measuring the impact of climate resilience should, in our view, not limit investment in this area. At COP27 in 2022, the UN Secretary General called for urgent action, highlighting that the funding available to support climate resilience is small compared to the $340bn estimated annual need in developing countries alone. As part of a global ecosystem that includes policymakers, companies and individuals, impact investors can generate attractive returns while playing an important role in filling this climate resilience funding gap.
1https://www.climatecentral.org/climate-matters/surging-weather-related-power-outages
Other sources: UDP_Perspectives-Adaptation-Metrics-WEB.pdf (iclei.org) | GIZ-2013_Adaptation_made_to_measure_second_edition.pdf (adaptationcommunity.net) | Adaptation Monitoring and Assessment Tool (AMAT) | CAKE: Climate Adaptation Knowledge Exchange (cakex.org).
Experts
Featured new perspectives
Asia Tech: Building the technology for everything, everywhere, all at once
Yash Patodia articulates the investment opportunities within generative AI and mixed reality - two themes that are supercharging the tech industry. He outlines how Asia is the bedrock of the innovation and where he believes the world’s future growth will be.
Will emerging Asia leapfrog the energy transition?
Decarbonizing while maintaining economic growth presents tremendous challenges for developing countries in Asia. Is technological innovation the solution?
Private biotech market: Innovation, valuations, and capital efficiency
Co-heads of biotech private investments I-hung Shih and Nilesh Kumar join host Thomas Mucha to explore today's private biotech market, highlighting the state of deal flow, valuations, and innovation.
URL References
Related Insights
Stay up to date with the latest market insights and our point of view.
Related Insights
Impact investing in emerging markets: Growing opportunities, shifting challenges
Members of our impact bond team discuss their evolving emerging markets opportunity set and the importance of a bottom-up approach to value creation.
Why an impact lens is an important tool in the fixed income investor's arsenal
Campe Goodman, Will Prentis and Oyin Oduya discuss how an impact lens can be an important tool in the fixed income investor's arsenal.
Three things I’m excited about in 2024
2023 was an eventful year for markets, with plenty of excitement, challenges and opportunities for fixed income investors. We believe our Global Impact Bond portfolio managers navigated them successfully.
Decoding impact expectations: best practices for impact investors and companies
We share three recommendations each for impact investors and companies to help them better understand and manage each other's expectations.
Why impact bonds make financial sense
We explore how impact bond investments can help deliver the dual benefits of attractive fixed income returns and material, additional and measurable impact.
Green horizons: How the shift toward sustainable finance may reshape fixed income markets
Three sustainability trends have the potential to reshape fixed income markets, leading to a range of new opportunities for investors.
More green shoots: Tracking trends in sustainable debt issuance
While growth in the sustainable debt market has been uneven, certain pockets offer substantial opportunities. Two of our fixed income investment professionals weigh in.
Activism – History and evolution in Japan
Investment Specialist Toshiki Izumi examines the history of shareholder activism in Japan, with particular emphasis on the differences between current and historical attitudes toward activism.
Blue bonds: long-awaited innovation or yet to make a splash?
Blue bonds – which aim to support projects related to ocean conservation – are on the rise. How effective are they and what do investors need to know before they invest?
How can impact investing help address the water scarcity challenge?
In acknowledgement of World Water Day, Louise Kooy-Henckel, Joy Perry and Paul Skinner highlight impact investing can help to address the world's water and sanitation crises.
Impact measurement and management practices
What constitutes an impact investment? How is impact measured? And, what are the benefits of impact investing? Our Impact Management and Measurement Practice Leader Oyin Oduya discusses our approach.
URL References
Related Insights