- Fixed Income Portfolio Manager
- About Us
- My Account
The views expressed are those of the authors at the time of writing. Other teams may hold different views and make different investment decisions. The value of your investment may become worth more or less than at the time of original investment. While any third-party data used is considered reliable, its accuracy is not guaranteed. For professional, institutional, or accredited investors only.
In our July 2022 blog post, Don’t be surprised if CLO equity surprises to the upside, we expressed a highly constructive outlook for collateralized loan obligation (CLO) equity capital deployment over the coming years. Fast forward to now: We believe the disruptions occurring across financial markets, particularly within an otherwise healthy CLO market, further support this view and lay the groundwork for potentially higher internal rates of return (IRRs).
CLO equity is currently battling several near-term headwinds that we believe will prove transitory, giving us growing conviction that returns should improve in 2023 and beyond on the strength of three potential tailwinds: 1) improving liability costs; 2) resilient fundamentals; and 3) attractive bank loan spread entry points.
Ongoing monetary policy tightening by the US Federal Reserve (Fed) has raised borrowing costs, with the aim of tightening financial conditions to rein in persistent inflation. As a consequence, spreads across a number of credit sectors have widened sharply.
Credit spreads on AAA rated CLO liabilities have risen to over 220 basis points (bps) as of this writing, which is at the 96% percentile relative to history.1 I believe these elevated levels are due to temporary supply/demand imbalances and not structural or credit headwinds. These stiff CLO financing costs are challenging the equity arbitrage (“arb”) and slowing new CLO issuance over the near term, as financing costs have risen by a greater magnitude than bank loan spreads. In my view, CLO liability costs have significantly overshot and should normalize over the next 12 – 18 months as the Fed’s rate-hiking cycle concludes. (At last check, market pricing of the final hike was during the first quarter of 2023.)
The bank loan market is coming off a period of historically strong credit performance, including default rates of less than 1%, according to Leveraged Commentary & Data. My view is that defaults will increase from current low levels closer to their historical average range of 3% – 4%, peaking over the coming 12 – 18 months. Even within the context of potentially higher defaults, there are three reasons I think the current credit cycle is healthy:
Taken together, I expect there to be heightened spread volatility as the market digests the path of future defaults, but the absolute level of likely defaults appears manageable and consistent with historical default cycles in which the CLO asset class has performed well.
Bank loan investors are generally compensated for default risk through correspondingly higher credit spreads and an illiquidity premium. Bank loan spreads ended September at 665 bps, in the 86% percentile historically.2 To put that in the context of expected defaults, this level of spreads implies a five-year cumulative default rate of 49%, which is almost twice as high as the worst five-year default experience since 1990 (27%).
In my view, market illiquidity is driving spreads and income to draconian levels, creating what I anticipate will be a favorable environment for capital deployment in the loan market over the next 12 – 18 months. This may present opportunities for skilled credit selection to potentially drive enhanced returns.
While the arb today is challenged due to higher liability costs, we believe the combination of lower liability costs going forward, benign default risk relative to history, and lofty bank loan spreads offers an attractive opportunity for investors to deploy capital into CLO equity over the coming years.
These factors should provide an attractive income profile for the asset class in the near term and upside potential through refinancing/reset and active reinvestment against a backdrop of heightened credit spread volatility over the intermediate term. Thus, we would encourage investors to look through the near-term “noise” and focus on the return opportunity that may be available to patient capital allocators.
1Source: Wellington Management, based on historical AAA new issuance. Historical spread analysis based on trailing 10 years of month-end spreads as of 30 September 2022. | 2Source: Morningstar Leveraged Loan Index. Historical spread analysis based on trailing 20 years of month-end discount margin, three-year average life.
Spread the risk: Our top three fixed income diversifiers for 2023Continue reading
CLOs: Poised to outperform in 2023?Continue reading
Can US bank loans “carry” investors through 2023?Continue reading
Take credit: Our five best credit market ideas for 2023Continue reading
High yield: Opportunity to pivot in 2023?Continue reading
Hidden in plain sight: Overlooked opportunities in investment-grade creditContinue reading
How to find potential in volatile European high-yield markets?Continue reading
Spread the risk: Our top three fixed income diversifiers for 2023
Fixed Income Strategist Amar Reganti highlights three types of strategies that may be well positioned to provide fixed income portfolio diversification going forward.
CLOs: Poised to outperform in 2023?
Collateralized loan obligations (CLOs) have been sparking investor interest lately — and with good reason, say Investment Director Andrew Bayerl and Investment Specialist Celene Klimas.
Can US bank loans “carry” investors through 2023?
Fixed Income Portfolios managers Jeffrey Heuer, CFA and David Marshak and Investment Director Nick Leichtman describe what they see as the most prudent approach to the bank loans asset class in 2023 and why.
Take credit: Our five best credit market ideas for 2023
Fixed Income Strategist Amar Reganti highlights credit market opportunities that he expects to arise over the course of 2023, against a backdrop of slowing growth.
High yield: Opportunity to pivot in 2023?
Our high-yield bond portfolio managers have a guardedly optimistic outlook on the market and believe security selection will be key to benchmark-relative outperformance in 2023.
Hidden in plain sight: Overlooked opportunities in investment-grade credit
Fixed Income Strategist Amar Reganti and Investment Specialist Geoff Austein-Miller highlight some relatively simple, straightforward ways to implement a positive view on high-quality corporate credit.
How to find potential in volatile European high-yield markets?
Fixed Income Portfolio Manager Konstantin Leidman discusses why European high-yield investors need to be ready for both further volatility and the emergence of new opportunities.
High-yield bonds in 2023: Fortune favours the patient
Amid ongoing dislocation in the high-yield market, Fixed Income Portfolio Manager Konstantin Leidman sees opportunities for investors to take advantage of potentially attractive valuations.
Can agency MBS bounce back from dismal performance?
Fixed Income Portfolio Manager Brian Conroy and two colleagues weigh in on the mortgage-backed securities (MBS) market in the wake of a very challenging month.
Credit market outlook: Partly sunny with a chance of good value
In his 2023 credit market outlook, Fixed Income Portfolio Manager Rob Burn highlights some potentially attractive opportunities in the wake of this year's market sell-off.