- Head of Multi-Asset Strategy
- About Us
- My Account
The views expressed are those of the author at the time of writing. Other teams may hold different views and make different investment decisions. The value of your investment may become worth more or less than at the time of original investment. While any third-party data used is considered reliable, its accuracy is not guaranteed. For professional, institutional, or accredited investors only.
While many asset owners recognize the value of a long-term mindset, it can be challenging to resist short-term instincts in volatile environments like the one we’ve seen in recent months. But asset owners who have a strategy to help them stay focused on the long term may avoid a number of potentially costly behaviors, including abandoning a thoughtfully selected allocation to a manager after a relatively short period of underperformance.
Our research shows that even the best managers have had to bounce back from periods of underperformance. Recently, for example, we used the eVestment database to look at the performance of active managers in the global core equity universe who had at least a trailing 10-year history (331 managers, 2012 – 2021). We evaluated their peer-universe-relative 10-year excess return rank (calculated using the MSCI All-Country World Index) to identify the top-quartile managers over the long term.
As shown in the dark-blue bars in Figure 1, 100% of these top-quartile managers experienced rolling one-year periods during which they lagged the median manager. Ninety-five percent did the same over rolling two-year periods, 82% over rolling three-year periods, 65% over rolling four-year periods, and so on.
We also looked at how much time these top-quartile managers spent among the bottom-quartile of their peers (light-blue bars). Remarkably, 92% of the top-quartile managers in the long term spent at least a year in the bottom quartile, and nearly half were in the bottom quartile over some three-year period. In some cases, three years of bottom-quartile performance is enough to get a manager put on a watch list and fired, even though that’s probably not what you want to do with a manager that will end up in the top quartile.
Our research found that even top-decile managers in the same global core equity universe — really the “cream of the crop” — have suffered periods of underperformance, with 100% lagging the median manager over rolling one-year periods. Nearly 90% did the same over rolling two-year periods, 63% over rolling three-year periods, and 37% over rolling four-year periods.
Importantly, we ran the same analysis for all active global core equity managers present in the market during an earlier 10-year time period (2006 – 2015) and found very similar results — suggesting that the near-term underperformance of highly skilled managers is likely a persistent phenomenon and not, say, a unique aspect of the post-GFC period.
Asset owners invest a lot of time and effort in the hunt for top managers, and we think this data suggests that those who’ve succeeded in finding them should think twice before abandoning their conviction just because a manager has had a bad run — even, potentially, an extended bad run.
For more on this topic, including strategies to help cultivate a long-term mindset, read our recent paper here.
Full speed ahead: China’s race to implement AIContinue reading
Trends and transformation: Ideas for the year aheadContinue reading
How geopolitics and the energy transition may reshape global tradeContinue reading
Early 2024 resolutions: Enjoy the yield but be smart with your surplusContinue reading
Insurance Quick Takes: Understanding the latest shifts in mortality and longevityContinue reading
Insurance Quick Takes: Unpacking potential impacts of newly proposed NAIC regulationsContinue reading
Full speed ahead: China’s race to implement AI
"China's AI landscape is dynamic and evolving rapidly. While challenges and uncertainties persist, China's commitment to AI innovation positions itself as a formidable player in the global AI arena." Yash Patodia, Global Industry Analyst and Terry Chen, Equity Research Analyst
Trends and transformation: Ideas for the year ahead
Explore our latest views on risks and opportunities across the global capital markets as we look ahead to the second half of 2023.
How geopolitics and the energy transition may reshape global trade
We explore the potential near- and longer-term market effects of deteriorating US/China relations, coupled with the shift toward a low-carbon economy.
Early 2024 resolutions: Enjoy the yield but be smart with your surplus
What should insurers expect from markets as we approach the end of the year? Tim Antonelli, Head of Multi-Asset Strategy – Insurance and Portfolio Manager, offers his views and identifies areas that may be worth a closer look.
Insurance Quick Takes: A look at the future landscape of US insurance climate risk oversight
Tim Antonelli, Head of Insurance Multi-Asset Strategy and Portfolio Manager, discusses the main points of a recent report published by the Federal Insurance Office (FIO), and the importance and impact to US insurers and insurance climate risk oversight.
Is bad news for the economy actually good news for markets?
While it has taken longer than expected, higher interest rates are starting to take their toll on the global economy and the "bad news is good news" market narrative could be changing. Members of our Investment Strategy team offer their macro and market outlook, including their latest views on equities, bonds, and commodities.
Insurance Quick Takes: Understanding the latest shifts in mortality and longevity
Tim Antonelli, Head of Multi-Asset Strategy – Insurance, discusses recent trends and patterns on mortality and longevity, why this topic is important for global insurers of all types and sizes today, and potential opportunities.
Insurance Quick Takes: Unpacking potential impacts of newly proposed NAIC regulations
Tim Antonelli, Head of Multi-Asset Strategy – Insurance, analyzes the potential impact for US insurers of a recent proposal that could allow the NAIC's security valuation office to override ratings of investments.
2023 Asia Pacific Investment Forum: Restrategise for an altered macro regime
At our 2023 Asia Pacific Investment Forum, a multidisciplinary group of Wellington’s specialists shared their unique perspectives on how to re-strategise for 2023 and beyond.
The denominator effect: Thoughts on the rise in private equity allocations
The sharp drop in public markets has left many asset owners with above-target exposure to private assets, raising a number of governance questions. Multi-Asset Strategist Adam Berger considers the likely responses and their potential pros and cons.