Lessons from 200+ years of energy evolution: What comes next?

In search of guideposts for the next transition in the energy economy, Multi-Asset Portfolio Manager Scott Elliott considers the evidence from previous transitions and draws conclusions that could shape future investment decisions.

Views expressed are those of the author and are subject to change. Other teams may hold different views and make different investment decisions. The value of your investment may become worth more or less than at the time of original investment. While any third-party data used is considered reliable, its accuracy is not guaranteed. For professional or institutional investors only.

Energy investors are facing uncertain times in the wake of the global coronavirus pandemic and the recent oil-price sell-off. In light of changing supply and demand fundamentals in energy markets, it remains to be seen what longer-term implications the current environment could have on the future of energy investing. However, in our view, there’s still no question that we are at the beginning of a major transition in the global energy economy, from a world dominated by fossil fuels to one with a rising share of renewable energy sources.

We believe we can draw insights from previous energy transitions to better understand how this longer-term transition from hydrocarbons to electrons may play out. Among the lessons we have learned, three stand out as our key takeaways from over two centuries of energy evolution:

  • Transitions in the energy economy take decades, are difficult to forecast, and are best considered in terms of scenarios and probabilities.
  • Cyclicality in oil prices should be expected, rather than the structural bear market some fear.
  • Though the pandemic and oil-price sell-off are making headlines, longer term, climate change and global carbon policy will be the big wild card.

The folly of forecasting

Forecasting in the energy markets has suffered from what I believe to be three common errors. First, there has been overreliance on extrapolation of the past, assuming things will go on as they have. Second, the impact of technological change has at times been overestimated. And third, there has been a tendency to forecast doom — i.e., we’re going to run out of fossil fuels.

The reality is that relatively little has changed in the energy markets since about 1940. Certainly things have become massively more efficient and larger in scale, but the basic structure of the system is surprisingly unchanged. In fact, the effectiveness and affordability of the current system has given it…

To read more, please click the download link below.

Recommended for you

DC plans: Three investment ideas for 2021
After an extremely trying 2020, DC plan sponsors are hopeful that 2021 will bring more opportunities than challenges. Director of Defined Contribution Jed Petty highlights three areas that may be worth focusing on in the new year.
January 2021
DC plans: Three investment ideas for 2021
,
A new framework for downside mitigation
Learn why Multi-Asset Strategists Nick Samouilhan and Adam Berger argue for a multi-pronged downside mitigation approach in today’s environment.
January 2021
A new framework for downside mitigation
,
Nick Samouilhan
 PhD, CFA, FRM
Insurers: A potent plan of attack for 2021
In this video and companion paper, Multi-Asset Insurance Strategist Tim Antonelli lays out several proposed areas of focus to help insurers successfully navigate 2021 after a grueling 2020.
January 2021
Insurers: A potent plan of attack for 2021
,
Tim Antonelli
 CFA, FRM, SCR
Climate: Today’s investment actions to address long-term challenges
This event replay from the 2020 Financial Times Investing for Good conference features Wellington's Director of Sustainable Investment Wendy Cromwell, discussing the importance of bridging the gap between climate science and finance, the kind of research and data required to support that, and work being done in conjunction with asset owners to help scientists and investors speak the same language.
January 2021
Climate: Today’s investment actions to address long-term challenges
,
Monthly Market Snapshot: November 2020
A monthly update on equity, fixed income, currency, and commodity markets.
December 2020
Monthly Market Snapshot: November 2020
,
Insurance Multi-Asset Outlook — Is the market rotation the real deal or just a head-fake?
In their latest multi-asset outlook for insurers, Tim Antonelli and Danny Cook argue that a durable rotation from growth- to value-type equity exposures may be in the offing for 2021.
December 2020
Insurance Multi-Asset Outlook — Is the market rotation the real deal or just a head-fake?
,
Tim Antonelli
 CFA, FRM, SCR
2021 Investment Outlook
As we head into the new year, thought leaders from across our investment platform share their views on pressing questions.
December 2020
2021 Investment Outlook
,
2021 ESG & Sustainability Outlook
In the wake of COVID-19, a record year for climate disasters, and rising calls for corporate responses to social justice, ESG and sustainability are in focus like never before. Members of Wellington's Impact Investing, Climate Research, and ESG Research Teams share what they plan to focus on in 2021.
December 2020
2021 ESG & Sustainability Outlook
,